Short answer: for most life, final expense and annuity agents, Facebook and Instagram are still where the leads are. LinkedIn is for business owners. YouTube builds trust. TikTok is mostly a long game. Pick one or two and do them well.
I’ve been buying Meta ads for 20+ years. Here’s how I’d think about it if I were running your agency.
Facebook and Instagram: still the lead engine
If you sell life, final expense, Medicare-adjacent or annuity products, your buyers are on Facebook. Instagram adds reach with a slightly younger crowd.
Our numbers back this up. One life insurance agency we ran Meta ads for generated 742 opportunities in a year at $17.73 each. You can see the full breakdown in our case studies.
What changed: Meta now puts insurance ads in a “Financial products and services” special ad category in the US. You can’t narrow by age, gender or ZIP code, and lookalike audiences are off the table. That sounds scary, but it just moves the work:
- Your creative does the targeting. An ad about protecting your family from funeral costs finds the right people without naming an age.
- Your data does the optimizing. Send real outcomes, like booked calls and sold policies, back to Meta so it learns who actually buys.
- Your follow-up does the closing. Shared leads go to five agents. Exclusive leads that you call in minutes, not hours, are where the money is.
LinkedIn: for business owners and key-person coverage
If you sell key-person, buy-sell funding, group benefits or executive coverage, LinkedIn is worth your time. The audience is smaller and clicks cost more, but one business client can be worth dozens of individual policies.
For most personal-lines agents, LinkedIn is a profile to keep current, not a lead source.
YouTube: the trust builder
People research insurance before they buy. Short videos answering real questions, like “How much life insurance do I actually need?” or “What does final expense cover?”, keep working for years.
YouTube rarely produces leads on day one. It makes every other channel convert better, because prospects already feel like they know you.
TikTok: a long game
TikTok can build a following fast, especially with younger families buying term life. But it takes a steady stream of content, and it’s harder to turn views into appointments.
If you love being on camera, test it. If not, skip it and put that time into follow-up.
So where should you start?
- Selling to individuals and families: Facebook and Instagram ads, plus fast follow-up.
- Selling to business owners: LinkedIn, plus a referral system with CPAs and attorneys.
- Building a long-term brand: YouTube, two short videos a month.
Don’t skip compliance
Insurance advertising is regulated state by state, and most carriers require approval before you run ads that mention their products. This is general info, not legal advice. Check your state rules and your carriers’ advertising guidelines before you launch.
Want to see the math for your agency?
Plug your numbers into our free Advisor & Insurance ROI Calculator. Or see how we run Facebook ads for insurance agents. Ready to talk? Apply to work with us.