Short answer: if your leads come from Facebook or Instagram ads, almost all of them are on a phone. If your site is slow, hard to tap or asks too many questions, they leave. And you paid for that click.
I’ve spent 20+ years buying ads. The fastest way I know to cut your cost per lead isn’t a new ad. It’s fixing the page the ad sends people to.
The 30-second phone test
Grab your phone and open your site like a stranger would. Then ask yourself:
- Did the page load in a couple of seconds, or did you stare at a white screen?
- Could you read the headline without zooming?
- Could you tell what you sell and who it’s for right away?
- Could you tap “Get a quote” or “Book a call” with your thumb on the first try?
If you answered “no” to any of these, you’re losing leads you already paid for.
1. Cut the load time
Big photos, sliders, chat widgets and pop-ups all slow a page down. On a phone with one bar of signal, every second costs you people.
Compress your images. Drop anything that doesn’t help someone get a quote. Test your page with Google’s free PageSpeed Insights tool and fix the biggest items it flags first.
2. Make the button impossible to miss
Your main action, like “Get My Quote” or “Book a Call”, should be big, high-contrast and above the fold. Repeat it as people scroll. Nobody should have to hunt for it.
3. Shorten the form
Every extra field costs you leads. On a phone, it costs you even more.
Ask for what you need to make the first call: name, phone, email, state and coverage type. Save the health and budget questions for the conversation.
4. Let them tap to call
Some buyers, especially older ones, still want to talk to a person. Put a tap-to-call button right at the top, and make sure someone actually answers it.
5. Match the page to the ad
If your ad talks about final expense coverage and the page talks about “comprehensive insurance solutions,” people bounce. The headline should finish the thought the ad started.
6. Follow up in minutes, not hours
The best mobile page in the world won’t save a lead you call back tomorrow. Set up an instant text and email when someone submits, and get them on the phone fast. Exclusive leads go cold quickly. Shared leads go cold even faster.
Don’t skip compliance
Insurance advertising rules vary by state, and many carriers require approval before you mention their products. If you text or call leads, make sure your form collects proper consent. This is general info, not legal advice. Check with your carriers and compliance contact before you launch.
Want to see what fixing this could be worth?
Run your numbers in our free Advisor & Insurance ROI Calculator. See how we build lead generation for insurance agents, or apply to work with us.